Perspectives · 01

On listening, before counsel.

By Carlos Magalhães · 2 min read

A young advisor arrives with frameworks. He has read the books, learned the models, prepared the analyses. He is expected to add value in the first meeting. The fastest path to that expectation is to recommend. The fastest path is also the surest way to recommend the wrong thing.

I learned this in my first years as an independent advisor. Often the brief is to validate a decision that has already been taken. The better answer is to wait. Attend the operations meetings, read the contracts, and ask each member of the leadership team one question: what this company was actually built to do. The answers are rarely the ones the owner expects.

The final advice can then be short. A few pages are usually enough, and the conclusion is often simpler than the plan it replaces.

What I learned in those early years was not a framework. It was a discipline. The discipline of withholding the obvious recommendation until the unobvious one becomes available. Of allowing the company to tell you what it is, rather than imposing what it should become.

Twenty years on, the practice continues. The frameworks have grown. The discipline has not changed.

Counsel begins where listening ends.

Carlos Magalhães

Contact


Begin a private conversation.

A short note describing the situation, the desired outcome, and the proposed timeframe. The principal replies within two working days.

Contact →